
Every firm you call this week will tell you the same thing: no fee unless we win. All of them mean it. None of them are telling you the whole story, because the sentence answers a question you did not ask.
What you actually want to know is what lands in your bank account at the end. That number is not the settlement figure, and the gap between the two is not a trick. It is arithmetic, and it is entirely knowable before you sign anything.
This is a guide to reading the fee agreement you are about to be handed, from Harding & Associates in Denver. It explains how contingency fees work, where the percentage typically changes, why case costs are a separate category that surprises almost everyone, and how to get from a gross settlement to a net cheque on paper. If you would rather have a Denver car accident attorney walk you through an agreement line by line before you commit to anyone, that conversation is free and carries no obligation.
The short answer
In a contingency arrangement, you pay no attorney fee up front and no attorney fee at all unless there is a recovery. Harding & Associates handles car accident claims on that basis: there is no cost to start and no fee unless we recover for you.
What that sentence does not cover, at any firm, is case costs. Those are a separate category; they are real money, and the way a firm handles them is the single biggest variable between one fee agreement and another. That distinction is the whole of section four below, and it is the thing to ask about before you sign.
How a contingency fee works
A contingency fee is a percentage of what is recovered rather than an hourly rate.
Three consequences follow, and they matter more than the percentage itself:
- You are never billed for time. No hourly rate, no six-minute increments, no invoice for a phone call. If your case takes two years instead of six months, the fee does not grow because of it.
- The firm carries the risk. If there is no recovery, there is no fee. That is what makes representation available to someone who cannot pay a retainer, which is most people three weeks after a crash.
- Your interests and the firm’s are aligned on outcome. Both sides do better when the recovery is larger. That alignment is the actual argument for contingency fees, and it is worth more than any percentage discussion.
The percentage is set out in a written fee agreement. Get it in writing, read it before you sign it, and keep your copy. Any firm that is reluctant to put its fee structure in a document you can take home and read is telling you something.
When the percentage steps up, and why filing suit changes it
Most contingency agreements are not a single flat percentage. They are tiered, and the tier changes at a defined event.
The reason is workload and risk, not opportunism. A claim that settles pre-suit is negotiated on paper. Once a lawsuit is filed, the file becomes a different animal: pleadings, written discovery, document production, depositions, expert retention and expert fees, motion practice, mediation, and trial preparation. That is a multiple of the work and a multiple of the money advanced, with no guarantee at the end of it.
The events that commonly trigger a step-up:
- Filing the complaint
- The case being set for trial
- An appeal being filed by either side
This is the first thing to pin down in writing. Not just what the higher percentage is, but the precise event that triggers it. “If we file suit” and “if the case goes to trial” are very different triggers, and a case can be filed and still settle at mediation months before any trial date. Ask which words are in your agreement.
Worth saying plainly: filing suit is often the right decision even though it raises the fee percentage, because it changes the insurer’s risk calculation and frequently produces a materially better result. The question is never the percentage in isolation. It is the net.
Fees versus case costs: the distinction that surprises people
This is where people get caught, so read this part twice.
The attorney fee is the percentage. It pays the lawyers.
Case costs are the out-of-pocket expenses of building the case. They are not the fee, they are not profit, and they get spent whether or not you ever collect anything. A firm typically advances them and is reimbursed out of the settlement.
Typical case costs in a Denver car accident claim:
| Cost | What it is |
|---|---|
| Court filing fee | Paid to the court to open a civil case |
| Service of process | Getting the defendant formally served |
| Medical records and billing retrieval | Providers charge per page or per request, and a serious case has thousands of pages |
| Deposition transcripts | The court reporter’s fee for each transcript |
| Expert witness fees | Usually the largest line item by a wide margin. Accident reconstruction, treating physician time, neuropsychology, life care planning, economics |
| Accident reconstruction and investigation | Scene work, vehicle inspection, download of vehicle data |
| Mediation fee | The mediator’s charge, commonly split between the parties |
| Trial exhibits and demonstratives | Preparing what a jury actually sees |
| Postage, courier, travel | Small individually, not nothing in aggregate |
Two questions decide how much this category actually affects you, and the answers differ between firms:
- Is the fee calculated on the gross settlement, or on the settlement after costs are deducted? This single choice changes your net by real money on any significant case. Section five shows exactly how much.
- What happens to advanced costs if the case is lost? Covered in section six.
Neither answer is a trap. Both are simply terms, and both are in the agreement. You are entitled to have them pointed out and explained before you sign, and if a firm will not do that, there is your answer about the firm.
A worked example: from settlement number to your cheque
Here is the arithmetic. The percentages below are an illustration of how the calculation runs, not a quoted rate from any firm. Substitute the numbers from the agreement in front of you.
Assume a gross settlement of $100,000, advanced case costs of $6,000, and a hospital lien and health insurance repayment obligation totalling $14,000.
Our firm works on a Method A: fee calculated on the gross
| Line | Amount |
|---|---|
| Gross settlement | $100,000 |
| Attorney fee, illustrated at 33.33% of gross | $33,3330 |
| Case costs reimbursed | $6,000 |
| Medical liens and subrogation | $14,000 |
| Net to client | $46,670 |
Method B: costs deducted first, fee calculated on the remainder
| Line | Amount |
|---|---|
| Gross settlement | $100,000 |
| Case costs reimbursed | $6,000 |
| Subtotal | $94,000 |
| Attorney fee, calculated at 33.33% of $94,000 | $31,330 |
| Medical liens and subrogation | $14,000 |
| Net to client | $48,670 |
Same settlement, same percentage, same costs. A $2,000 difference in what the client takes home, produced entirely by which line the fee is calculated on. On a case with heavy expert costs, the gap is considerably larger.
Three things this example is designed to show:
- The settlement number is never the take-home number. Anyone who quotes you a gross figure and stops has not finished the sentence.
- Medical liens are usually the biggest single deduction after the fee, and they are frequently negotiable. Reducing a lien puts money directly in the client’s pocket and does not change the fee. It is one of the most valuable and least visible things a lawyer does, and it is closely tied to how MedPay repayment works after a Colorado car accident.
- Ask for this exact table for your own case before you sign. A firm that can produce it in five minutes has thought about your net. A firm that cannot has thought about its fee.
What happens to case costs if the case is lost
This is the question people are actually asking when they say they do not believe “no fee unless we win,” and it deserves a direct answer rather than a slogan.
The attorney fee position is uniform: no recovery, no fee. That part is not in dispute anywhere.
Advanced case costs are a separate term, and firms genuinely differ. There are three common positions:
- The firm absorbs the costs. The client owes nothing at all.
- The client remains responsible for advanced costs. The agreement says so, and it is enforceable.
- Something between the two, often a cap, or absorption below a threshold with responsibility above it.
None of these is improper. All of them are permitted. The only bad outcome is not knowing which one you signed. Ask the question in exactly these words: “If we lose, do I owe you anything, including costs?” Then ask to be shown the paragraph that says so. A straight answer takes fifteen seconds.
What the free consultation actually covers
A consultation is not a sales meeting, and you are not obliged to hire anyone at the end of it. A useful one covers:
- Whether you have a viable claim at all, honestly, including when the answer is no
- What deadlines are already running in your situation
- What insurance coverage exists on both sides, including your own uninsured and underinsured coverage, which is frequently overlooked
- What the realistic range of outcomes looks like given what is known today
- The fee structure, in writing, explained rather than handed over
- What happens next, and on what timeline
You can bring the crash report, your insurance declarations page, any letters from adjusters, and a list of every provider you have seen. None of it is required to have the first conversation. If you are still weighing whether to involve a lawyer at all, the firm covers that separately in whether your case needs an auto accident attorney and in whether hiring an attorney gets you more money.
Six questions to ask before you sign any fee agreement
Take these to every firm you are considering. The answers are more revealing than anything on a website, including this one.
- What is the percentage, and does it change? If it changes, what is the exact event that triggers it, in the words of the agreement?
- Is the fee calculated on the gross recovery, or after case costs are deducted?
- If we lose, do I owe anything, including advanced costs? Show me the paragraph.
- Who actually handles my file day-to-day, and will I be able to reach them?
- Will you negotiate my medical liens, and is that included in the fee or billed separately?
- Can I take this agreement home and read it before signing? The answer should be yes without hesitation.
A firm that answers all six plainly is a firm that will tell you the truth later, when the news is worse. That is the actual thing you are shopping for. There is more on this in the firm’s tips on hiring a personal injury attorney.
Frequently asked questions
How much does a car accident lawyer cost in Denver?
Car accident claims are handled on a contingency basis, meaning the fee is a percentage of the recovery rather than an hourly rate, with nothing payable up front and no attorney fee if there is no recovery. The percentage and its tiers are set out in the written fee agreement, and you should compare that document, not a headline number, between firms.
Do I pay anything if I lose my car accident case?
No attorney fee. Whether you owe advance case costs depends on the specific agreement you signed, and firms take different positions on that. Ask the question directly and ask to be shown the clause before you sign.
What is the difference between attorney fees and case costs?
The fee is the percentage that compensates the lawyers. Case costs are out-of-pocket expenses spent building the case: filing fees, records retrieval, deposition transcripts, expert witness fees, and mediation charges. They are usually advanced by the firm and reimbursed from the settlement.
Why do contingency fees increase if a lawsuit is filed?
Because litigation multiplies both the work and the money advanced. Discovery, depositions, experts, and trial preparation are a different order of effort from a pre-suit negotiation, and the costs advanced rise sharply with no guarantee of recovery.
Does the lawyer take a percentage of my medical bills too?
The fee is generally calculated on the total recovery, and medical bills are then paid or repaid from the client’s share. This is exactly why the worked example above matters, and why getting liens negotiated down has such a direct effect on your net.
Is a contingency fee agreement in Colorado required to be in writing?
Reputable firms put contingency fee terms in a written agreement signed before work begins, and you should insist on one. Read it, ask about anything unclear, and keep your copy.
Can I negotiate the percentage?
Sometimes, depending on the strength and size of the case. It is a reasonable question to ask. It is also worth remembering that the lowest percentage does not automatically produce the largest net, because the fee is a share of a number that a better-run file makes bigger.
The number that matters is the net
A firm charging a lower percentage on a worse result pays you less. The percentage is one input into your net recovery, and it is neither the largest nor the one you have most control over. What actually moves the number is the quality of the file: whether the injuries were documented properly, whether the liability evidence was preserved, whether the demand was built to be taken seriously, and whether the liens were negotiated at the end.
If you want to see what that has produced for other Denver clients, our results are published, and there is more on what actually drives settlement value and on negotiating with insurance companies elsewhere on this site.
When you are ready, contact Harding & Associates for a free consultation with Phil Harding. Bring the fee agreement from any other firm you are considering. We will go through it with you in plain language, whether or not you end up hiring us.

Mr. Harding not only practices law, but has real life experience in being the C.E.O. of a small steel company that creates mechanical parking devices (see www.hardingsteel.com). After graduating from law school in 1990, Phil worked for larger firms, and tried cases in the civil, criminal and domestic relations arena. Currently Phil practices in the areas of Civil Litigation; Appellate Work (Colorado Court of Appeals, Colorado Supreme Court, 10th Circuit Court of Appeals, United States Supreme Court) Wrongful Death; Dram Shop Actions (Liquor Store and Bar Liability) Bad Faith Breach of Contract; Construction Defects and Defense; Corporate Disputes; Plaintiffs’ Personal Injury Litigation.










